CASE

Download full text EN

Case Name

In Re the Parenting of R.A.A. Case Number DA 25-0712

INCADAT reference

HC/E/NL 1758

Court

Country

UNITED STATES OF AMERICA

Name

The Supreme Court of the State of Montana

Level

Appellate Court

Judge(s)

Laurie McKinnon, Cory J. Swanson, Katherine M. Bidegaray, Beth Baker, James Jeremiah Shea

States involved

Requesting State

UNITED STATES OF AMERICA

Requested State

NETHERLANDS - KINGDOM IN EUROPE

Decision

Date

21 April 2026

Status

Final

Grounds

Habitual Residence - Art. 3

Order

Appeal dismissed, return refused

HC article(s) Considered

-

HC article(s) Relied Upon

-

Other provisions

Uniform Child Custody Jurisdiction and Enforcement Act (UCCJEA)

Authorities | Cases referred to

Monasky v. Taglieri, 589 U.S. 68, 140 S. Ct. 719 (2020); Lozano v. Montoya Alvarez, 572 U.S. 1, 134 S. Ct. 1224 (2014); In re Matter of the Parenting of A.H.S., 2025 MT 57, 421 Mont. 196, 571 P.3d 1002; In re Marriage of Sampley, 2015 MT 121, 379 Mont. 131, 347 P.3d 1281

Published in

-

SYNOPSIS

Synopsis available in EN

One child wrongfully removed – Married parents – Father national of USA – Mother national of USA and the Netherlands – Mother had full legal custody and father rights of access – Child lived in USA until June 2022 and then again from May until August 2023  – Application for return filed with the courts of the Netherlands in January 2025. In September 2025 the father filed an Emergency Motion for Temporary Custody and Petition for Permanent Parenting Plan in the Montana District Court – Appeal dismissed – Main issue: UCCJEA, The Montana District Court correctly determined that it did not have child custody jurisdiction over the child since Montana was no longer her ‘home state’.

SUMMARY

Summary available in EN

Facts

The parents married in 2009 in the USA. The father was a USA citizen and the mother a dual citizen of the USA and the Netherlands. They had a child in 2015. 

Between June 2022 and May 2023 the mother and child lived in the Netherlands and the child attended school there.

The mother returned to the USA in May 2023 but left again for the Netherlands in August 2023, without the knowledge or consent of the father. 

In January 2025 the father filed a petition in the District Court of The Hague for the return of the child invoking the 1980 Hague Abduction Convention. In March 2025, the District Court of The Hague denied father’s petition as more than a year had passed since the child's arrived in the Netherlands and she had become settled in her new environment. In May 2025, the Court of Appeal of The Hague dismissed the father’s appeal.

The mother feared returning to the USA due to an ongoing criminal investigation against her for alleged child abduction

In September 2025, the father filed an Emergency Motion for Temporary Custody and Petition for Permanent Parenting Plan in the Montana District Court. The District Court dismissed this petition and motion based on its conclusion that it did not have jurisdiction to overturn the decision of the Court of Appeal of The Hague and that Montana was no longer the ‘home state’ of the child as she had not lived there for more than two years. 

The father appealed to the Montana Supreme Court.

Ruling

Appeal dismissed. The Montana District Court correctly determined that it did not have child custody jurisdiction over the child since Montana was no longer her ‘home state’ and Montana courts had a duty to recognise and enforce valid foreign judgments registered in the state.

Grounds

Habitual Residence - Art. 3

According to the UCCJEA, Montana was no longer the ‘home state’ of the child as she had not lived there for more than six months. 

Determination of the child’s ‘home state’ under the UCCJEA is distinct from their ‘habitual residence’ under the 1980 Hague Abduction Convention. In this case the Netherlands District Court determined that the child had established her habitual residence in the Netherlands since she had consistently attended the same primary school for approximately four years, was doing well in school, had multiple friends and participated in extracurricular activities, and had formed meaningful bonds with her maternal family there.