AFFAIRE

Télécharger le texte complet EN

Nom de l'affaire

Deravil v. Jean, No. 25-3636 (6th Cir. May 8, 2026)

Référence INCADAT

HC/E/US 1761

Juridiction

Pays

États-Unis d'Amérique

Degré

Deuxième Instance

États concernés

État requérant

France

État requis

États-Unis d'Amérique

Décision

Date

21 April 2026

Statut

Définitif

Motifs

Opposition de l'enfant au retour - art. 13(2)

Décision

Recours rejeté, retour refusé

Article(s) de la Convention visé(s)

13(2)

Article(s) de la Convention visé(s) par le dispositif

-

Autres dispositions

International Child Abduction Remedies Act (ICARA)

Jurisprudence | Affaires invoquées

-

Publiée dans

-

SYNOPSIS

Synopsis disponible en EN

1 child wrongfully retained at age 13 – Child lived in Haiti until 2015 and then in Martinique until 2023 – Appeal dismissed, return refused – Main issue: Article 13(2) the child objected to returning to Martinique and was of an age and degree of maturity that her views should be taken into account. 

RÉSUMÉ

Résumé disponible en EN

Facts

The child was born in Haiti in 2012 and lived there until 2015. In 2015 the child moved to Martinique with her great-aunt and great-uncle and lived there for eight years. In that time she did not see her biological parents but had monthly phone calls with them.

The parents moved to different countries before settling in the USA in 2021. In 2023 the child went to spend the summer with the parents but did not return to Martinique as planned. 

The great-aunt and great-uncle filed an application under the 1980 Hague Abduction Convention for the return of the child to Martinique. 

The parents argued that the great-aunt and great-uncle had originally wrongfully removed the child in 2015 and that the child objected to returning. 

The District Court refused to order the return of the child. She was of an age and degree of maturity for her views to be taken into account and opposed returning to Martinique. 

The great-aunt and great-uncle appealed the decision. 

Ruling

Appeal dismissed, return refused. 

Grounds

Objections of the Child to a Return - Art. 13(2)

At 13 the child was of an age and degree of maturity for her views to be taken into account. The exception requites maturity, not fully developed adult-like behaviour and the grandaunt and granduncle were not able to point to any evidence, beyond the court transcript, showing that the child lacked the proper degree of maturity.

The child did not want to return to Martinique as she did not feel safe there and claimed she had been physically punished and threatened by her greataunt and greatuncle.

In the assessment of a child's maturity and the nature of the child's objection, an appellate court reviewing a transcript is not in the same position as the trial judge who observed the child directly.