Grave Risk - Art. 13(1)(b)|Objections of the Child to a Return - Art. 13(2)
Order
Return ordered subject to undertakings
Article(s)
13(1)(b)13(2)
Synopsis
Three children wrongfully retained at ages 11, 9 and 7 – Joint custody – Children were born in England and moved to Portugal in 2022. They lived there until the mother wrongfully retained them in England in December 2025 – Application for return filed on 29 December 2025 – Return ordered – Main issues: Return ordered with undertakings offered by the father and conditional on the mother securing a Portuguese resident permit; Article 13(1)(b): the return of the children would not expose them to an intolerable situation; Child’s objections: though the eldest child objected to returning, these objections were not such that the court should decline to make a return order.
1 child wrongfully retained at age 4 – Father national of Australia – Mother national of UK – Joint custody – Child lived in Australia until February 2025 – Application for return filed in February 2026 – Return ordered – Main issue: Article 13(1)(b), the allegations of domestic violence did not reach the grave risk threshold and that, though there would be a “virtually inevitable” impact on the mother’s mental health, she would be able to access support in Australia.
Objections of the Child to a Return - Art. 13(2)|Grave Risk - Art. 13(1)(b)
Order
Return refused
Article(s)
13(1)(b)13(2)
Synopsis
Two children wrongfully removed at ages 11 and 7– Divorced parents – Father national of USA – Mother national of UK – Joint custody, mother primary carer – Children lived in USA until December 2024 – Application for return filed in September 2025 – Return refused – Main issues: Article 13(2), the elder child had strong objections to returning; Article 13(1)(b), there was a grave risk of harm should a return be ordered based on the risk the mother could not travel with them, the mother’s mental health and financial instability.
Two children wrongfully removed at ages 5 and 7 – Married parents – Joint custody – Children lived in Paraguay until November 2024 – Application for return filed on 15 September 2025 – Return refused – Main issue: Article 13(1)(b), grave risk of harm to the children and no protective measures to ameliorate the risk.
1 child wrongfully retained at age 13 – Child lived in Haiti until 2015 and then in Martinique until 2023 – Appeal dismissed, return refused – Main issue: Article 13(2) the child objected to returning to Martinique and was of an age and degree of maturity that her views should be taken into account.
One child wrongfully removed – Married parents – Father national of USA – Mother national of USA and the Netherlands – Mother had full legal custody and father rights of access – Child lived in USA until June 2022 and then again from May until August 2023 – Application for return filed with the courts of the Netherlands in January 2025. In September 2025 the father filed an Emergency Motion for Temporary Custody and Petition for Permanent Parenting Plan in the Montana District Court – Appeal dismissed – Main issue: UCCJEA, The Montana District Court correctly determined that it did not have child custody jurisdiction over the child since Montana was no longer her ‘home state’.
One child allegedly wrongfully retained at age five – National of Germany and the USA – unmarried parents – Father national of USA – Mother national of Germany and the USA – Joint custody but delegated decision-making to the mother – Child moved around significantly between Germany and Hawai’i – Return refused – Main issue: Habitual residence, the child had spent much of her life moving and had meaningful ties to more than one place. For three years she had lived primarily in Hawai’i, built relationships and attended school. Her eight-month stay in Germany failed to reflect the same level of continuity.
One child wrongfully removed at age 4 – Married parents – Father national of Ireland – Mother national of Israel, Ireland and UK – Joint custody – Child lived in Ireland until June 2025 – Appeal to Supreme Court dismissed, return ordered